Comments for:

Lily Allen Agrees With You, Thinks You Should Pay For Music
10 Comments... Comments are closed while we transition to Disqus

Sammy James    Said...

Lily is right. I thought about this yesterday, after having read about Floyd and other UK acts claiming that they would be hurt by anti-piracy laws.

Well, maybe they WOULD be hurt. And I don't care. I stopped listening to Pink Floyd after their (excellent) 1986 album "Momentary Lapse of Reason." I never had a thing for Radiohead, and most other big UK acts (Coldplay, U2, et cetera) leave me feeling, well, cold.

I have had it with this whole "live music is king... recorded music should be FREE so that we can all enjoy the spoils of the Internet revolution!!!" Where I grew up, you paid for music -- or you got taken to the back room at Strawberries to call your parents -- AFTER THE POLICE HAD BEEN NOTIFIED.

If you think that this is a joke, then you are obviously either too young or too stupid to care. Or both. We all need to start understanding that music requires work. Great music requires a TON of work. And work SHOULD = $$$ -- NOT "free for everyone."

Thank you.

15-Sep-09 06:05 PM

fight mp3    Said...

Sorry Lilly but if you are so dump to sign a contract with a record label, that does not care for you aka let´s you pay the bills then you don´t DESERVE any better.

As a hint: you can have your album up at iTunes for $100 a year. This works for thousands of independent artists.

And another one for you: there is a very simple equation that sells your music: "connect to Fans + give them reason to buy = Cash"

This is not about paying or not for music, it´s about artists who think the world OWES them for making music.

This is not the case.

15-Sep-09 07:44 PM

Radiophobic    Said...

See, the problem with the music industry isn't file sharing, its the labels. She is complaining about being in debt to them. The world has taken a paradigm shift insofar as to music distribution, and the only people who don't seem to get it are the record labels, and those who choose to live under them.

In ten years time, labels will be an anachronism. People will still be wanting good music, and artists will still be able to make a living off of it. They just won't have a syndicate scheming practically everything off the top.

15-Sep-09 08:04 PM

JDonahue    Said...

I'll echo the sentiment that Lily's problem isn't piracy, it's the fact that she's approaching the industry through the old mammoths that can't keep up with the times. She's on the wrong side of the revolution and she has no one to blame but herself.

16-Sep-09 02:13 AM

Aaron    Said...

Lily is right. She's a musician not a T-shirt designer, so she should be able to make money from her music and not advertising overpriced shirts.

16-Sep-09 08:40 AM

"The Man" is you    Said...

What's worrying here is there's a mindset of people who are eager to believe this social meme that if you go into the business yourself instead of slave to a record company you'll reap the benefits. Unfortunately in the real world all the small fry get hit by piracy and sharing also, the sharers just use the large record bosses as their justification.

What's even more worrying is this carries over to other industries like computer games, people will even steal in mass numbers a game download that only costs 57p, something most pirates 5 years ago would avoid when they still had some real social justification.

16-Sep-09 08:45 AM

Radiophobic    Said...

Artists are going to find its easier to make money through licensing than it is through albums. Nearly every 'real person' I have read from or met that actually makes money off of music says that exact same thing.

Despite whether or not you believe that, I think its pretty obvious the only way you are going to stop illegal filesharing is by stopping the internet. Artists and labels are going to need to find a different model or else they aren't going to be able to survive.

Using the Simon Cowell example, do you think he makes most of his money nowadays off of album sales? Honestly, I don't know the numbers so I can't say for certain. But would I venture to guess that most of it is through television. In any event, he is making a killing because he has figured out a different model for music distribution that doesn't require record sales to produce a profit.

17-Sep-09 04:39 AM

Radiophobic    Said...

I am going add that I don't condone illegal file sharing, I think artist should be able to make a living off of music. Its just kind of hard to argue that its a fact of the life now. Unfortunately this is a good example of Darwinian economics at play. You can fight against evolution all you want, but it doesn't change the fact that it is happening.

17-Sep-09 04:57 AM

brain    Said...

she looks cute

24-Sep-09 09:10 AM

Kelly Allen    Said...

It's a tricky one this. I understand that artists are losing money through file sharing but I have no idea how they are going to stop it. It's no different to borrowing your friend's CD and burning a copy but people's music collections are much larger these days because of file sharing. When I was a teenager we used to tape the top 40 off the radio, tape friends albums etc. Purchasing an album was a much bigger deal. You would save up, go to the record store and listen to the album in the booth loads of times before you finally parted with your money. Then when you got the album home you devoured it. You knew every note, every word and every inch of the artwork. Today music seems so much more disposable and the quality isn't there anymore. It's churned out so quickly and albums often only have a couple of good tracks. I don't know, but I would imagine that file sharing has forced artists to go out and perform live more than they used to. If you discover an artist through file sharing you may then go and see them live or even buy the CD if you love file sharing then benefits them. Lily's objections seem to stem from the fact that she is still in debt to the record company so maybe that is where the problem lies.

27-Sep-09 02:31 AM

Comments are closed while we transition to Disqus

Leave your comment

Subscribe to these comments
Join our newsletter for latest news/competitions
email (only required for subscription)

Enter the text you see above: